Head-to-Head Comparison

TradeDay vs Blue Guardian

An honest, data-driven comparison to help you pick the right prop firm. We compare drawdown rules, challenge costs, profit splits, trading conditions, and more — no bias, just facts.

TradeDay

4.1

Futures prop firm offering competitive pricing with up to $750K in allocations and trader-friendly rules.

Visit TradeDay

Blue Guardian

4.6

Innovative prop firm featuring the Guardian Shield risk management system. Offers 24-hour payout guarantee and scaling up to $4M with multiple funding models.

Visit Blue Guardian

Side-by-Side Comparison: TradeDay vs Blue Guardian

Metric

TradeDay

Blue Guardian

Max Drawdown

Daily Drawdown

Profit Target

10%

Profit Split

80/20 → 90/10

85/15 → 90/10

Challenge Cost

$99 - $499

$87 - $897

Trading Period

Unlimited

Min Trading Days

Leverage

Exchange margin

1:100

Instruments

Futures

Forex, Crypto, Indices, Commodities

Account Sizes

$25K, $50K, $100K, $150K, $250K

$10K, $25K, $50K, $100K, $200K

Scaling

Max allocations $750K

25% account increase every 3 months at 12% profit, up to $4M

News Trading

Allowed

Not Allowed

Weekend Holding

Not Allowed

Allowed

EA / Bots

Allowed

Rating

4.1/5

4.6/5

The Verdict: TradeDay vs Blue Guardian

The best choice depends on your trading style, risk tolerance, and goals. Here's our breakdown by trader profile:

Best for Beginners

TradeDay

TradeDay offers more forgiving drawdown rules, making it easier for newer traders to get started.

Best for Aggressive Traders

TradeDay

TradeDay provides 8% max drawdown allowance, giving aggressive trading styles more breathing room.

Best for Long-term Scaling

Blue Guardian

Blue Guardian offers better scaling potential: 25% account increase every 3 months at 12% profit, up to $4M.

Best for Overall Value

Blue Guardian

Blue Guardian earns 4.6/5 in our analysis, with a strong balance of rules, cost, and trader experience.

TradeDay Pros & Cons

Generous allocation limits

Competitive pricing

Up to 90% profit split

Clear evaluation rules

No time pressure

Futures only

Limited instrument variety

Newer brand

Cannot hold over weekends

Mid-range recognition

Blue Guardian Pros & Cons

24-hour payout guarantee or 100% profit split

Guardian Shield risk management system

Scaling up to $4M

85% base profit split (higher than most)

Overnight and weekend holding allowed

No news trading on funded accounts

Guardian Shield can close trades at 1-2% loss

Second Shield breach terminates account

US traders restricted from some features

Fee refund only after 4th payout

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, TradeDay or Blue Guardian?

It depends on your trading style. TradeDay offers 8% max drawdown and a 80/20 → 90/10 profit split, while Blue Guardian offers 6% max drawdown and a 85/15 → 90/10 split. Blue Guardian has a higher overall rating at 4.6/5.

What is the cheapest option between TradeDay and Blue Guardian?

TradeDay challenges start at $99 - $499, while Blue Guardian starts at $87 - $897. Compare account sizes and what's included before choosing based on price alone.

Can I use EAs or trading bots with TradeDay and Blue Guardian?

TradeDay allows EAs/bots. Blue Guardian allows them. Always verify the latest rules on each firm's website.

What are the drawdown rules for TradeDay vs Blue Guardian?

TradeDay has a 8% max drawdown and 4% daily drawdown. Blue Guardian has a 6% max drawdown and 4% daily drawdown. Use our free Drawdown Calculator to find your safe lot size for either firm.

How long do I have to pass the TradeDay vs Blue Guardian challenge?

TradeDay gives you Unlimited. Blue Guardian gives you Unlimited. Both require a minimum of 5 and 5 trading days respectively.

Which firm has a better profit split, TradeDay or Blue Guardian?

TradeDay offers a 80/20 → 90/10 profit split, while Blue Guardian offers 85/15 → 90/10. Higher profit splits mean more of your trading profits go to you.